Pick an age, then pick up to ten players. Everything below is what each of them had actually done by that birthday — every season, every trophy — and a ranking that shows its working. Nought is projected and nothing is estimated: a season counts only once it has finished.
Comparing a footballer to a quarterback on raw numbers is meaningless, so nobody is scored on totals. Each player is measured against the other greats in his own league at the same age, then those within-league standings are combined:
The percentile is taken inside each league because that is the only fair comparison available; the cross-league score then rests on how far ahead of his own peers a player was, plus the trophies, which are the same currency everywhere.
Championships are credited to every player on the winning club's roster in a season he played. A man who appeared in three regular-season games for a champion and not in the playoffs is still credited, which is the convention league record books disagree about; it is stated here rather than buried.